Gips vs Cleft lift

I saw two CRS in the Washington DC area. Both diagnosed me with pilonadal.

The first, at Hopkins, recommended going straight to cleft lift. The doctor was extremely nice and experienced, and said this is the best way to prevent reoccurrence.

The second, at medstar, recommended the Gips. She explained there was an 80-85% success rate, and she would opt to try this first before going for a more intensive procedure like cleft.

If you had both options, which would you select? Im all for less invasive, but think it would be dumb to select the procedure with a higher reoccurrence rate.