Help me with my Enchantments itinerary please

I have a core zone permit and am able to backpack for 3 nights. Need to be off the trail the last morning by about 11am.

Option 1: Hike it end to end starting at the Colchuk side. Spend first 2 nights in the core zone and last night at Nada lake to have a short enough hike out in the morning.

Option 2: Hike it out and back. Go up Aasgard day 1 and spend 3 nights in the core zone. Camp near-ish top of Aasgard the last night and hike down Aasgard back to the car the last day.

I guess the question is, is it worth hiking back down Aasgard to get an extra night in the core. And, will it take a significantly different amount of time to hike the 6 miles 3600ft out from Nada as compared to the 5 miles and 4400ft down from Aasgard?