Whether Logan Cheated or Not, He Sucked

I’m on my fourth rewatch and I need to hear opinions on this. Logan and Rory were in a committed relationship and it was going very well. Then, they have their fight and they do not technically or at least officially break up. He took it as a definite break up, even though neither of them actually broke up with the other. She thought of it as more of a fight and space.

Then, at his sister’s wedding she finds out he has slept with/fooled around with essentially every bridesmaid during their fight/break. Naturally, she storms out and breaks up with him.

Logan finally gets to speak with her that same night and his logic is that in his mind they were broken up, therefore he did not think he was cheating. He said something along the lines of: you have to believe that in my mind we were not together so I was not cheating. Then she just says I believe you and BAM she’s back in the relationship??? (I know she goes out to see Jess to try to take ‘revenge’ in a sense [but failed], which was wrong because if she didn’t forgive Logan, she shouldn’t have gotten back with him).

I just don’t accept this because regardless of what he thought or believed, Rory was way too quick to forgive him. Personally, someone moving on that quickly and frequently, while I was still faithful to them, would have me never wanting them back. It seems like it should’ve bothered her so much more but within the same night she just caves and says it’s fine??

I’m on my fourth rewatch and I need to hear opinions on this. Logan and Rory were in a committed relationship and it was going very well. Then, they have their fight and they do not technically or at least officially break up. He took it as a definite break up, even though neither of them actually broke up with the other. She thought of it as more of a fight and space.

Then, at his sister’s wedding she finds out he has slept with/fooled around with essentially every bridesmaid during their fight/break. Naturally, she storms out and breaks up with him.

Logan finally gets to speak with her that same night and his logic is that in his mind they were broken up, therefore he did not think he was cheating. He said something along the lines of: you have to believe that in my mind we were not together so I was not cheating. Then she just says I believe you and BAM she’s back in the relationship??? (I know she goes out to see Jess to try to take ‘revenge’ in a sense [but failed], which was wrong because if she didn’t forgive Logan, she shouldn’t have gotten back with him).

I just don’t accept this because regardless of what he thought or believed, Rory was way too quick to forgive him. Personally, someone moving on that quickly and frequently, while I was still faithful to them, would have me never wanting them back. It seems like it should’ve bothered her so much more but within the same night she just caves and says it’s fine??