I have a question

My Van dijk(95 rating) has 97 speed 81 acceleration, saliba 100/100 , rudiger 100/97 But when i play live matches , my van dijk never commit a mistake , never allows opponent to outrun him While Saliba and rudiger sometimes make a mistake in keeping control, tackling etc. Should i redo leaving his card or not ? Does the overall performance relies on rating or on stats ? I think rating bcz vvd perfoms far better than full fit saliba rudiger